Facebook Pixel Noscript Image

The holidays have a way of convincing us we can do it all. Host dinner. Wrap gifts. Decorate the house. Bake the perfect pie. I love pie, but my pie-making adventures haven’t exactly inspired confidence.

One of our college friends has spent years perfecting the art of pie making, winning blue ribbons at his state fair and generously sharing his award-winning pie and pie crust recipes with us. I have the recipes, pie pans, rolling pins, measuring cups, flour sifters, and enough kitchen gadgets to outfit a small bakery. What I apparently don’t have is a successful pie-making track record.

Case in point: one Thanksgiving, I made pumpkin pies and proudly shared one with our neighbor before heading home to finish preparing for the holiday. Later that day, we cut into the pie I kept for our family and immediately realized I’d forgotten the sugar. Not reduced it. Not measured it wrong. Forgotten it entirely.

The pie was terrible.

Panic set in as I realized my neighbor had the exact same pie sitting on her counter. Before anyone could cut into it, I was racing across the street to rescue that pie before it became the Thanksgiving dessert everyone remembered for all the wrong reasons.

Thankfully, I made it in time.
The pie did not.

That wasn’t my only pie-baking mishap. Another year, I spent hours picking fresh blueberries and making a homemade pie from scratch, only to discover I had accidentally turned the oven to broil instead of bake. Let’s just say that pie never made it to the table either.

At this point, I’ve accepted an important truth: while I love eating homemade pie, I’m perfectly happy letting someone else do the baking.

Homemade Holiday Pies Made Easy

That’s where Machine Shed comes in.

Whether you’re hosting Thanksgiving dinner, Christmas dinner, a holiday party, or simply need dessert for a family gathering, Machine Shed’s homemade holiday pies make entertaining a little easier and a lot sweeter.

Machine Shed table close up with four different pies on display

Our pies are baked fresh and made from quality ingredients, including fruit pies loaded with real fruit and rich cream pies topped with real whipped cream. Better yet, they’re a generous 11 inches, significantly larger than the typical 8- or 9-inch pies you’ll often find elsewhere. When family and friends gather around the holiday table, a little extra pie is never a bad thing.

Machine Shed offers a wide variety of holiday pies, including apple, cherry, blueberry, peach, strawberry rhubarb, pumpkin, pecan, chocolate cream, banana cream, coconut cream, Snickers™ pie, pumpkin cream, and other seasonal favorites. Whole pies are available with just 24 hours’ notice, making them perfect for holiday gatherings, office parties, family celebrations, or those moments when you’d rather spend your time deciding what to wear than worrying about what to bake.

Let’s Talk About Holiday Pies Everyone Saves Room For

Whether you’re looking for pumpkin pie, pecan pie, apple pie, or a rich cream pie, Machine Shed has a holiday favorite for every gathering.

In our family, we’ve learned that ordering one pie is dangerous. Two pies are safer. Three pies practically guarantee leftovers.

At least that’s what we tell ourselves.

After all, the Shed’s homemade 11-inch pies are larger than the typical 8- or 9-inch pies you’ll find elsewhere. That’s great news if you’re feeding a crowd. If you’re hoping for leftovers, however, I’d still recommend ordering two.

An Honorable Mention: The Apple Dumpling

While technically not a pie, I would be remiss if I didn’t mention another longtime favorite: the Machine Shed Apple Dumpling.

Machine Shed delicious apple dumpling sitting in a bowl with two apples in the background

Back in 1978, founder Mike Whalen was searching for the perfect signature dessert. Inspired by Aunt Grace’s recipe, our homemade apple dumpling was born and quickly became a guest favorite. Served warm from the oven and paired with cinnamon ice cream, it has earned honorary membership in the pie family.

For Those Brave Enough to Bake Their Own

If you’re determined to tackle homemade holiday pies this year, our gift shops can help. You’ll find Machine Shed cookbooks, pie rings, pie cutters, flour sifters, measuring cups, mini rolling pins, and other kitchen gadgets perfect for holiday baking.

Who knows? Maybe this will finally be the year I’ll attempt one of those blue-ribbon recipes.

Then again, considering my track record, perhaps not.

The Sweetest Holiday Shortcut

The holidays are busy enough without stressing over pie crusts and oven timers.

If you’ve mastered homemade pies, I admire you. If you’re more like me, Machine Shed’s homemade holiday pies are a pretty delicious backup plan.

Machine Shed close up of a row of different pies

Because when friends and family remember a holiday gathering, they probably won’t remember who made the pie. They’ll remember gathering around the table, saving room for dessert, and hoping there was one last slice left for them.

Machine Shed’s homemade 11-inch holiday pies are available as whole pies to go with just 24 hours’ notice.


Pilgrim Pie Recipe

From the Machine Shed Cookbook, available in all gift shops

Ingredients

  • 1 unbaked pie crust
  • 1 cup pancake syrup
  • 1 cup sugar
  • 2 eggs, beaten
  • 1 cup coconut
  • 2 oz. softened butter
  • 1 cup uncooked oatmeal
  • ½ tsp. salt
  • 1 Tbsp. vanilla
  • ¾ cup chopped pecans

Directions

  1. Preheat oven to 325°F.
  2. Cream together the eggs, sugar, and butter.
  3. After mixing for 1-2 minutes, add the remaining ingredients.
  4. Pour into the unbaked pie shell and bake for approximately 45 minutes.
  5. Serve with whipped cream.

One additional tie-in with the recipe: in the cookbook, we feature a photo of Jeff Grunder and his family with a caption regarding how it was made by both his grandmother, Daisy, and his mother, Rhonda, every Thanksgiving as a tradition.

 

Written by The Farmhouse Friend